This is, without apology, a rant driven by a coach leaving and his new school and a feeling of betrayal and all of that that happened tonight.And, it is written by someone who has worked at the same place for 26+ years, which, I realize, in 2010, is ungodly weird.
Is there no loyalty in the world anymore?
Believe me, I'm not naive. I know all about opportunity and advancement and wanting to climb the ladder or to be the best or to maximize one's potential. I know that these are All-American values preached all the way from the halls of Montezuma to the shores of Tripoli.
But, seriously, is loyalty a dead concept?
Perhaps I should go back and find a definition. After all, what is loyalty? Merriam-Webster defines "Loyalty" as "the quality or state or an instance of being loyal." Which is completely un-fucking-helpful. So, on we go, following the link to "Fidelity," which the same site defines as "faithfulness to something to which one is bound by pledge or duty."
And, yeah, that will do the job for us, won't it?
My first problem is this: half of me believes that an institution that treats one well deserves loyalty, and half of me believe that it doesn't. Because, after all, it is an institution, and, as such, is an unfeeling, somewhat intangible entity whose name is invoked mainly in an attempt to inspire loyalty.
My second problem is this: when we throw out the concept of an institution, we are left with people--players or students or colleagues or whomever is impacted by an early departure. Because that's what disloyalty is about, isn't it? It isn't that someone leaves; it's that that person leaves before his or her time.
Once upon a time, there was a Spanish teacher at this school who left at mid-year to bicycle his way through South America. He was a likeable enough guy, I guess, and people would want to give me updates about him. "Not interested," I would say, "He is dead to me." Those people would look at me surprised. "He left his students hanging in the middle of the year to go biking in South America," I would say, "I have no respect for that at all." And I didn't. And I don't. There is an unspoken agreement that a teacher will hang with his or her students for a year, come Hell or high water.What goes through your head when you screw other people in order to do what is best for you? Does the money make it okay? Do you tell yourself it was the chance of a lifetime and that you had to take it? Do you tell yourself that it was God's will? What other lies can the mind conjure up?
I fear that, in America, unspoken agreements aren't effective anymore, because if they are unspoken, if they are not on paper, perhaps notarized, able to be upheld in a court of law, then they don't mean anything at all. If so, that is very, very sad. That means that unless you hold me to it, unless it was written into my contract, then I am in no way bound to honor it.
I believe that when you take on a team, a class, a job, you see it through until it is completed, at least until you meet some open-to-interpretation definition of completed. You don't have to win the title or anything, but you do have to make the things right that weren't right when you took whatever it was on. If you were hired to do a specific job, then you stay with that job until the person that hired you is reasonably satisfied. Not everything in this life is immediate. Not every opportunity comes at us in such a way that we have act now or forever regret it. No, there are plenty of opportunities that arise exactly because we stuck with something that maybe people didn't think we would stick with. Yeah, we came back for our senior year or, yeah, we helped return a program to its winning ways, or, yeah, we finished out the school year, or, yeah, someone simply asked us to do something for x amount of time and we were true to our word.
That's loyalty. And that's right.
I stumbled across the live Bruce at Addicted To Vinyl.com. Great site.
I stumbled across the live Bruce at Addicted To Vinyl.com. Great site.
11 replies:
Three comments:
1: As an ESPN writer (TMQ) writes: When you hire a coach who's only in it for himself, you get a coach who's only in it for himself.
2: Orgeron reportedly contacted the 8 UTK recruits who are on-campus to enroll at mid-year and told them not to go to class tomorrow so they could more easily transfer to USC.
3: Al Davis and BJ Coleman: vindicated.
Pat Forde killing USC: http://sports.espn.go.com/ncf/columns/story?columnist=forde_pat&id=4820927
Bicycle his way through South America?
Guess we can rule out Senor Bong.
Yes, I went there.
One could argue that loyalty is precisely why Kiffin is going to USC, since that's where he rose most strongly in the ranks. His first love, so to speak. His loyalty to USC far outranks his loyalty to UT, and Vollies should have darn well known that before yesterday.
Second, I wonder if you were motivated to write this last year when Fulmer got fired?
Third, what Hank said.
Fourth, Tiger Woods and Lane Kiffin live in a different world than us. A world we created for them, where their gifts are determined to earn them demigod-like status (see: John Calipari, Midnight Madness, UK) and then act surprised when these people act like demigods. It feels disingenuous that we help build them up yet act so shocked and awed when they take advantage of it.
Cool blog you got here. It would be great to read a bit more concerning that topic. Thanks for posting that data.
Joan Stepsen
Gadgets and gifts
In theory, loyalty is nice, but in reality it's not always sufficient. Sometimes it's a luxury with a price too high. Think about this, Bob. If you were offered 10 million dollars and you could finish out the school year without penalty, you surely would, out of loyalty. But, what if the situation was here's 10 million bucks, but you have to quit and take it right now. School year be damned, I don't think we'd be seeing you around campus. That's the more relevant situation here. If he doesn't take his dream job now, he might not get the opportunity again. He seems like a jerk, but I don't blame him here.
Also, if you are truly loyal, do you kick Mad Dog out of your band for Mighty Max? Do you ditch your long time band of friends for a soulless group, including(gasp!) Randy Jackson. Ah well, the Boss has apologized for that one...and did give each ESB member $2 million along with the pink slip!
Bob responds:
1)I don't see the relevance of Phil Fulmer or Vinnie "Mad Dog" Lopez. It's not disloyal to replace people who are no longer effective in their positions. Though, admittedly, there are kinder ways of doing it.
2) I'm not shocked or awed; I'm pissed off. I don't wish he were still coach; I lament how he has harmed what he's left behind.
3) Trout, I don't have to respond to your scenario until that 10 mill flashes before my eyes. Until then, I'm takin' the high road.
4) What Hank said.
5) Billy, while I somewhat grasp your perception of loyalty, I would ask you to review the University of Kansas' reaction to Roy Williams taking the UNC job. It may have seemed to UNC that Roy was returning loyally to his roots, to "his first love, so to speak," but it sure didn't play that way in Kansas. I'm surprised that anyone would expect that it would.
Loyalty be damned. I wanna hear more about this Senor Bong person.
Hank,
Al Davis vindicated? Al Davis is a senile old fool who has run his franchise into the ground. His hope is that he can tie his situation with Kiffin up long enough that he just eventually forgets it.
Bob,
Loyalty is great, and I consider it one of the traits that I look for most in friendship. However it is truly really hard to find people who live up to a truly loyal standard.
A senile old fool? Darrius Heyward-Bey was the steal of the 2009 NFL Draft. How did he last to pick #7? Shrewd decisions like that win championships.
Thom - As for Senor Bong, a young Goofy along with BOTG poster Lamont coined the term about 10 years ago. However, Goofy has been instructed by one of the Bottom of the Glass writers to look forward and not backward. Therefore, I can't divulge anything about the short tenure of the beloved and legendary Senor Bong.
there are 2 kinds of loyalty. one, loyalty regarding personal relationships and two, loyalty to an institution (aka your employer). the second type is at issue here and these days it really doesn't exist much; it's morphed into loyalty to oneself.
Post a Comment